Co-founder and Managing Director of axelity ag | Product strategist of the Swiss signing solution actaSIGN®
Written Form and BGB Section 126a: When Germany Requires a QES
The electronic signature has long been established in German law — yet many businesses still rely on printing, signing by hand, scanning and mailing. The legal position is clear: the eIDAS Regulation provides a unified European framework, and the German Civil Code (BGB) defines exactly when the electronic form can replace the written form. This article explains the legal foundations, the three signature levels and provides practical guidance for German businesses.
eIDAS — the European Legal Framework
Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 — known as the eIDAS Regulation (Electronic Identification, Authentication and Trust Services) — has been directly applicable in all EU member states since 1 July 2016. In Germany, no national transposition law is required — eIDAS applies directly.
The Regulation governs:
- The three levels of electronic signatures (SES, AES, QES)
- The requirements for Trust Service Providers (TSPs)
- The cross-border recognition of electronic signatures within the EU
- The non-discrimination principle: an electronic signature may not be denied legal effect solely because it is in electronic form (Art. 25(1) eIDAS)
The Trust Services Act (Vertrauensdienstegesetz, VDG)
In addition to the eIDAS Regulation, Germany enacted the Trust Services Act (Vertrauensdienstegesetz, VDG). It regulates national supervision of Trust Service Providers — the responsible authority is the Federal Network Agency (Bundesnetzagentur) — and contains penalty provisions for violations. However, the substantive requirements for electronic signatures are defined by eIDAS itself, not by the VDG.
The Three Signature Levels
SES — Simple Electronic Signature
The simple electronic signature is the lowest level. It encompasses any form of electronic data attached to a declaration of intent — from a typed name in an email to clicking an "Accept" button.
Identification: No special requirements. The signer's email address suffices.
Evidential value: Low. In the event of a dispute, the party relying on the signature must prove its authenticity (free assessment of evidence under Section 286 of the Code of Civil Procedure, ZPO).
Typical use cases: Internal approvals, meeting minutes, delivery notes, general business correspondence.
AES — Advanced Electronic Signature
The advanced electronic signature meets four criteria under Art. 26 eIDAS: it is uniquely linked to the signatory, it enables identification of the signatory, it is under the signatory's sole control, and it is linked to the data in such a way that any subsequent change is detectable.
Identification: Email address and mobile phone number (two-factor verification).
Evidential value: Medium to high. The technical link to the signatory substantially strengthens the ability to prove authenticity.
Typical use cases: Employment contracts (open-ended), rental agreements, purchase orders, order confirmations, commercial agent agreements.
QES — Qualified Electronic Signature
The qualified electronic signature is the highest level. It is based on a qualified certificate and created using a qualified signature creation device (Art. 3(12) eIDAS). In Germany, it is legally equivalent to a handwritten signature under BGB Section 126a.
Identification: Strong two-factor authentication through a recognised Trust Service Provider.
Evidential value: Very high. The presumption of authenticity applies — the opposing party must prove that the signature is not genuine, rather than the party relying on it.
Typical use cases: Consumer credit agreements, fixed-term employment contracts, and other declarations for which the law requires written form without excluding the electronic form.
BGB Section 126a — When Electronic Form Replaces Written Form
The German Civil Code regulates written form in Section 126 BGB and the electronic form as its equivalent in Section 126a BGB:
If the statutory written form is to be replaced by the electronic form, the issuer of the declaration must add their name and provide the electronic document with a qualified electronic signature. — BGB Section 126a(1)
In practical terms, this means: wherever the law requires "written form" and neither excludes the electronic form (as Sections 623 and 766 sentence 2 BGB do) nor prescribes the signatory's own hand or notarial authentication, the QES can replace the handwritten signature.
This is a powerful provision. It applies across civil law, employment law and commercial law — anywhere the BGB or special statutes require written form without mandating notarial involvement.
Which Contracts Require Which Signature Level?
The following table provides an overview of common contract types in German business practice, the minimum signature level required and the relevant legal basis.
| Contract type | Minimum requirement | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| General business correspondence | SES | Freedom of form |
| Purchase contract (movable goods) | SES | Freedom of form (Section 433 BGB) |
| Open-ended employment contract | SES/AES recommended | Freedom of form, but note the Verification Act (Nachweisgesetz) |
| Fixed-term employment contract | QES | Section 14(4) TzBfG, Section 126a BGB |
| Consumer credit agreement | QES | Section 492(1) BGB, Section 126a BGB |
| Personal guarantee (Buergschaft, non-merchant) | Paper with handwritten signature | Section 766 sentence 2 BGB — QES is not enough |
| Termination or termination agreement (employment) | Paper with handwritten signature | Section 623 BGB — QES is not enough |
| Residential tenancy termination | QES | Section 568 BGB, Section 126a BGB |
| Temporary staffing contract | QES | Section 12 AUeG |
| Real estate purchase contract | Notarial authentication | Section 311b BGB — QES is not sufficient |
| Prenuptial agreement | Notarial authentication | Section 1410 BGB — QES is not sufficient |
Important: Where the law requires notarial authentication or the signatory's own hand (e.g. holographic wills under Section 2247 BGB), the QES does not satisfy the form requirement.
Cross-Border Signing: Germany and Switzerland
German businesses working with Swiss partners face a particular situation: Switzerland is not an EU member, and there is currently no official mutual recognition of electronic signatures between the EU and Switzerland.
A Swiss QES under ZertES is therefore not automatically a QES under eIDAS in the EU. In practice, you choose the qualified signature by where the document has to be valid: actaSIGN signs via Swisscom Trust Services, which is recognised by OFCOM and listed on the EU Trusted List.
This means: actaSIGN offers the qualified signature under ZertES for Switzerland (QES CH) and under eIDAS for the EU and the EEA (QES EU). For Germany, the QES under eIDAS (QES EU) applies; it is recognised as a QES in all EU member states (Art. 25(3) eIDAS).
On 29 January 2025, the Swiss Federal Council instructed DETEC and the FDFA to draw up a negotiating mandate for mutual QES recognition with the EU. According to OFCOM, talks with the European Commission are under way; an agreement before the end of 2026 is considered unlikely (as of 19 August 2026). Until there is an agreement, choose QES EU for documents that have to be valid in Germany and QES CH for documents that have to be valid in Switzerland.
Practical Tips for German Businesses
1. Match the signature level to the use case
Not every document requires a QES. Many everyday business transactions are not subject to form requirements — an SES or AES is sufficient. The QES is required when the law prescribes written form.
2. Check data protection and hosting
German businesses are subject to the GDPR. Check where your e-signature provider hosts its data. actaSIGN operates its infrastructure in a Swiss data centre — without international cloud providers such as AWS, Azure or Google Cloud. Switzerland's data protection level is recognised as adequate by the EU (adequacy decision).
3. Use a recognised TSP
Ensure that the Trust Service Provider is listed on the EU Trusted List. Only then are the QES created recognised as qualified across the entire EU — including Germany.
4. Create internal policies
Define which document types require which signature level. A simple internal policy creates clarity and avoids uncertainty among employees.
5. Evaluate integration with existing systems
actaSIGN offers a REST API, SSO via OpenID Connect, and integrations with DMS systems such as Kendox and docuvita — both established solutions in the German and Austrian markets.
Conclusion
The legal framework for electronic signatures in Germany is clear: the eIDAS Regulation provides the overarching framework, and BGB Section 126a governs the equivalence with written form. For most business transactions, SES or AES is sufficient — QES is used where the law requires written form.
With an e-signature provider based on an EU-listed Trust Service Provider and offering Swiss hosting, German businesses can sign legally and securely — both domestically and across borders.
Legal sources
The laws named in this article, in their official text:
- Swiss Federal Act on Electronic Signatures (ZertES, SR 943.03; German, French, Italian)
- Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 (eIDAS)
- German Civil Code (BGB, official English translation)
- German Part-Time and Fixed-Term Employment Act (TzBfG; German)
- General Data Protection Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR)
Note: This article provides general orientation and does not constitute legal advice. For form-sensitive or cross-border transactions, the specific legal situation should be assessed case by case.