Co-founder and Managing Director of axelity ag | Product strategist of the Swiss signing solution actaSIGN®
Is a Digital Signature Legally Valid? How It Differs from an Electronic Signature
Short answer: yes. A digital signature is legally valid in Switzerland if the law does not prescribe a particular form for the contract. That is the normal case: contracts need no form unless the law says otherwise (Art. 11 CO). Where the law requires written form, only a qualified electronic signature (QES) with a qualified time stamp replaces the handwritten signature (Art. 14 para. 2bis CO). A pasted image of a signature or a scan does not meet written form. And a few transactions still need paper or a notary.
This article shows which signature is enough for which contract, how a "digital signature" differs from an "electronic signature", and how to create one.
When is a digital signature legally valid?
What matters is not the term but the form the law requires for the specific transaction. There are three cases:
| Form requirement | Examples | What is enough |
|---|---|---|
| No form (the normal case, Art. 11 CO) | Quotes, orders, sales of movable goods, most employment contracts (Art. 320 CO), contracts for work | Any electronic signature is valid. SES or AES; the choice is a question of evidence |
| Statutory written form | Consumer credit agreement (Art. 9 CCA), apprenticeship contract (Art. 344a CO), post-contractual non-compete clause (Art. 340 CO), assignment of a claim (Art. 165 CO) | Only a QES with a qualified time stamp (Art. 14 para. 2bis CO), or a handwritten signature |
| Stricter form | Sale of land (public deed, Art. 216 CO), handwritten will (Art. 505 CC), guarantee by an individual above CHF 2,000 (public deed, Art. 493 CO) | No electronic signature; paper or a notary |
One trap sits in your own contract: if the parties agreed that changes "require written form", the requirements of statutory written form apply in case of doubt (Art. 16 CO). Then even an otherwise form-free amendment needs a QES. More on this in the article HR documents in Switzerland.
Legally valid is not the same as provable
Even where any signature is valid, the levels differ in how well you can prove in a dispute who signed what, and when:
- SES (simple electronic signature): a typed name, a click or a pasted image. Valid for contracts without a form requirement, but weak evidence.
- AES (advanced electronic signature): uniquely linked to the signer and to the document, so that any later change can be detected (Art. 2 ZertES). With an identity check, for example an SMS code, it is the sensible standard for most business contracts.
- QES (qualified electronic signature): an advanced signature created with a qualified signature creation device and based on a qualified certificate from a recognised provider. With a qualified time stamp it is equivalent to a handwritten signature.
You will find the detailed comparison of the three levels in the article Difference between SES, AES and QES.
Digital signature or electronic signature: the difference
In everyday business most people say "sign digitally" and mean: sign a contract on screen without printing it. Technically, the terms describe three different things:
- Electronic signature is the legal term. It covers every way of giving consent electronically and is divided into the levels SES, AES and QES. In Switzerland, ZertES (the Federal Act on Electronic Signatures) sets the requirements for these signatures; the Code of Obligations decides which form a contract needs.
- Digital signature is the technical method. A hash value is calculated from the document and encrypted with the signer's private key. The public key shows whether the document has been changed since. AES and QES are built on this method.
- "Digital signature" in everyday speech often means nothing more than an image of the handwritten signature pasted into a PDF. In law that is at most an SES.
In practice this means: don't ask whether the signature is "digital" or "electronic". Ask which signature level the contract needs.
How to create a digital signature
With a signing platform a document is signed with legal effect in a few minutes:
- Upload the document: you upload the PDF or Word document.
- Choose signers and signature level: you enter the email addresses and choose SES, AES or QES.
- Sign in the browser: the signers receive a link and sign in the browser, depending on the level with an email confirmation, an SMS code or Mobile ID. They do not need an account.
- Receive the signed document: all parties receive the signed PDF with an audit trail.
The page Sign PDF shows how this works with a PDF. More tips on the process are in the article Sign documents online.
And in Germany, Austria and the EU?
In the EU, the eIDAS Regulation applies. An electronic signature must not be denied legal effect solely because it is electronic (Art. 25(1) eIDAS). A QES has the same legal effect as a handwritten signature (Art. 25(2) eIDAS).
In Germany, the electronic form replaces statutory written form only with a QES (Section 126a BGB), and it is excluded altogether for terminating employment (Section 623 BGB) and for a guarantee declaration (Section 766 sentence 2 BGB). Details are in the article Written form and BGB Section 126a.
For cross-border contracts: a Swiss QES under ZertES is not automatically a QES under eIDAS in the EU. Choose the qualified signature according to where the document must be valid. More on this in the article Cross-border signing in the DACH region.
What businesses gain
- Speed: contracts that used to spend days in the post are often signed the same day, even with several parties.
- Cost: printing, postage and filing disappear. The article The true cost of a paper contract does the maths.
- Evidence: an audit trail records who signed when. With AES and QES the signature also shows whether the document was changed afterwards. In a dispute that holds up far better than a scanned signature.
- Any location: people sign at the office, at home or on the road, in a browser.
Signing digitally with actaSIGN
actaSIGN is a Swiss signing platform that runs in the browser. It supports SES, AES and QES under ZertES (Switzerland) and eIDAS (EU). There is one price per organisation from CHF 49 per month; signatures and QES are included in every plan, and signers are free.
Legal sources
The laws named in this article, in their official wording:
- Code of Obligations (CO, SR 220): Art. 11, 14, 16, 165, 216, 320, 340, 344a and 493
- Federal Act on Electronic Signatures (ZertES, SR 943.03): Art. 2
- Consumer Credit Act (CCA, SR 221.214.1): Art. 9
- Civil Code (CC, SR 210): Art. 505
- Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 (eIDAS): Art. 25
- German Civil Code (BGB): Sections 126a, 623, 766
Note: This article provides general orientation and does not constitute legal advice. For form-sensitive or cross-border transactions, the specific legal situation should be assessed case by case.